Our story - Hartsdale, New York - Est. 1980

Six generations
of jewelry.
One community.

Toby's Jewelry was built on something that can't be manufactured - a genuine love for people, a European craftsmanship heritage spanning six generations, and 46 years of showing up for Westchester every single day.

6th
Generation in
the jewelry business
46 yrs
Serving
Westchester
10,000+
Custom pieces
designed and made
3rd gen
Customers who
swear by us
Where it began

A family trade.
A new country.
A store built from scratch.

Jewelry runs in the blood. Moishe comes from a long line of craftsmen - six generations deep - rooted in a European tradition of precision, artistry, and pride in the work. When he and Toby came to Westchester in 1980, they brought that heritage with them.

Moishe had spent years casting and designing fine jewelry pieces - work that found its way into the showcases of Macy's, Corvette's, and other prominent retailers of the time. When Toby left her work at a local clothing store to join him, they opened their first store together on Central Ave in Scarsdale. They built the building that housed the store. They built a reputation that preceded them everywhere.

Over the decades they put down roots in Hartsdale - a tight-knit community that embraced them completely, and a store that has quietly become one of the most trusted names in Westchester jewelry.

For 46 years this store ran on handshakes, pen and paper, and the kind of personal relationships that no software can replicate. We're modernizing now, but the values don't change.

"
We are the sixth generation in this business. That's not something we take lightly - it's something we feel every day when we open the door.
Moishe - Toby's Jewelry - Hartsdale, NY
Photo of Toby
"Same great experience 10 years later. My first visit was for my wedding - the warmth of this store is unlike anywhere else I've ever been."
Alexandra K. - Yelp - Loyal customer since 2015
The heart of the store

Toby wasn't just
behind the counter.
She was the reason
people came back.

Every store has a face. Toby's had a soul. In 46 years, Toby became something rare - a presence that people genuinely needed. Not just for jewelry, but for a kind word on a hard day. For the right advice at the right moment. For the warmth of someone who remembered your name, your family, and your story.

She matched couples. She brought fresh cheesecake when someone was struggling. She had a gift for knowing exactly what each person needed - whether that was a stunning piece of jewelry or simply someone to talk to. She was a connector of people in the truest sense.

Two years on, customers still drop off flowers, cards, and homemade goods. They call to check in. They ask about her every single day. Some people cry. That's not a customer base - that's a community that loves her back.

Toby is resting and recovering. Her warmth, her spirit, and her legacy live in every corner of this store - and in the hearts of everyone who was lucky enough to know her.
The craftsman

A legacy built
by hand. Passed
down with pride.

Six generations of craft don't lie. Moishe's eye for design, his understanding of stone and metal, and his ability to turn a vision into a finished piece are things that simply can't be taught - they're accumulated over a lifetime, and passed down through generations before him.

He built pieces that sold in New York's finest stores. He built a building on Central Ave. He built a reputation in Westchester that spans decades and three generations of families. That foundation - that standard of craft and integrity - is what the next generation of Toby's is built on.

Casting and design - decades of experience creating pieces sold in major New York retailers.

10,000+ custom designs - and counting, for families across Westchester and beyond.

Six generations deep - a jewelry heritage that predates the store itself.

A legacy continuing - the next generation carrying forward the same standards, values, and love for the craft.

Photo of Moishe
The journey

46 years. One family.
One community.

1980
First store opens

Toby and Moishe open their first store on Central Ave in Scarsdale, bringing a six-generation jewelry legacy to Westchester.

1980s
Building the foundation

They build the very building that houses the store - a testament to how seriously they took putting down roots in Westchester.

2005
Hartsdale becomes home

Decades of craft, community, and commitment - built one relationship at a time across Westchester.

Today
Three generations of loyalty

Third-generation customers, 10,000+ custom pieces, and a community that ships jewelry across the country rather than trust anyone else.

The Westchester community

People don't just shop here.
They belong here.

There are jewelry stores everywhere. What you can't find everywhere is a place that knows your name, remembers your grandmother's ring, and sends your order across the country because you won't trust anyone else with it. Third-generation customers. Families who've marked every milestone - engagements, anniversaries, births, losses - at this counter. That's not retail. That's something else entirely.

"Every single piece I wear was sold to me by Toby and designed by Moishe."
Said proudly. Said often. Said by more customers than we can count.
3rd genCustomers who grew
up with the store
12Westchester neighborhoods
- Nextdoor Favorite
46 yrsOf showing up
every single day
CoastCustomers ship jewelry
from across the US
Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite

Recognized across 12 Westchester neighborhoods including Hartsdale, Scarsdale, White Plains, Yonkers, Tarrytown, Bronxville and more.

Voted by the community - not paid placement
In their own words

What 46 years of trust
sounds like.

*****

"Same great experience 10 years later. My first visit was for my wedding in 2015. Toby and Moishe are truly one of a kind - there is no other store like this in Westchester."

Alexandra K. Yelp - Loyal since 2015
*****

"Best jewelry store in Westchester - beautiful and very different jewelry, and if you want they will design and create a truly special piece just for you."

Westchester customer Yelp - Verified
*****

"Honest, reasonable, and a pleasure to work with every single time. I've been sending people here for years and every single one of them thanks me for it."

R.G. Nextdoor - Verified
Come meet us

The counter is open.
You're always welcome.

No appointment needed. Walk in, look around, say hello. We've been here 46 years - we're not going anywhere.

1 S Central AveHartsdale, NY 10530
Mon-Thu 10am-6pm - Fri 10am-12pmSun 10am-4pm
(914) 288-8066Call anytime during hours