Custom Jewelry Design - Hartsdale, NY

A piece made
for you.
Only you.

Bring us a sketch, a photo, a stone, or just an idea - we'll design and create a one-of-a-kind piece that's entirely yours. Custom pieces start from $500, with a free quote before any work begins.

$500
Starting price
for custom work
3-4 wks
Typical turnaround
start to finish
10,000+
Custom designs
created
46 yrs
Crafting for
Westchester
Pendant example
Band example
Earring example
Custom doesn't mean expensive

Most custom pieces are
more affordable than you think.

We work with every budget - from a simple personalized band to a complex multi-stone design. Every piece is quoted before any work begins, and there's never a surprise at the end.

All quotes are free, with zero obligation to proceed.

$500
Starting from
What we can create

Any piece. Any metal.
Any vision.

These are examples of the custom work we produce. Every piece is made to order - bring inspiration and we'll make it real.

Engagement Rings
Engagement Rings
Created for Westchester engagement rings with lab or natural diamonds in white gold, yellow gold, or platinum.
Free quote
3-4 weeks - Consultation required
Pendants & Necklaces
Pendants & Necklaces
Custom pendants featuring diamonds, colored stones, or meaningful symbols - set in your choice of metal.
Free quote
3-4 weeks - Consultation required
Bands & Fashion Rings
Bands & Fashion Rings
Eternity bands, anniversary rings, fashion rings - custom designed to your exact specifications.
Free quote
3-4 weeks - Consultation required
Earrings
Earrings
Custom studs, drops, and hoops. Match an existing piece or start something entirely new.
Free quote
3-4 weeks - Consultation required
Bracelets
Bracelets
Tennis bracelets, bangles, charm bracelets - handcrafted to your design in any precious metal.
Free quote
3-4 weeks - Consultation required

Images shown are representative design examples. Every piece is made to order - bring your inspiration and we'll create something uniquely yours.

Our most popular service

Already have a stone?
Let's reimagine it.

Your grandmother's diamond. A stone from a ring you no longer wear. A piece that holds meaning but not the right setting anymore. Bring it to us - we'll design something new around it, keeping every bit of the sentiment while creating something you'll actually wear every day.

We evaluate your existing stones at no charge
You approve the new design before anything is made
Your original stone is set in a brand new piece
Often more affordable than starting from scratch
Call for a Private Consultation
Your old piece
Existing ring
>
We extract
Your diamond
>
New design
Custom setting
>
Result
Yours forever

Same stone. New life. Full sentiment.

The process

From idea to finished piece
in 3-4 weeks.

Every custom piece follows the same careful process - design-led, quality-controlled, and handled with care from start to finish.

01
Free consultation
Share your vision, inspiration, budget, and timeline. Bring photos, sketches, or existing pieces.
Day 1
02
Design & quote
We sketch and render your piece in detail. You receive a full quote before anything is made. No surprises.
Days 2-4
03
You approve
Review the design and quote. Request changes. Only when you're completely happy do we move forward.
Days 4-6
04
Casting & fabrication
Your piece is cast in the exact metal and specifications you approved.
Week 2-3
05
Stone setting & polish
Stones are sourced, set, and the piece is finished to a fine polish. Every detail checked against the original design.
Week 3
06
Ready to wear
Pick up your finished piece in store or arrange delivery. Comes with full documentation and care instructions.
Week 3-4
What to bring

Don't worry about
coming prepared.

Most customers arrive with just an idea. That's enough. Here's what you can bring - and what we'll do with it.

I
Just an idea
Describe what you're imagining. We'll sketch it out together and help you visualize the final piece.
P
A photo or inspiration
Screenshot from Pinterest, a photo of something you love, a magazine clipping - we'll work from anything visual.
D
An existing stone
Loose diamond, stone from old jewelry, family heirloom - we'll evaluate it and design a new piece around it.
O
An old piece to repurpose
A ring you no longer wear, jewelry from someone you've lost - we'll reimagine it into something you'll love again.
Materials

Available in every
precious metal.

White Gold
14k & 18k - Most popular for diamond settings
Yellow Gold
14k & 18k - Classic, warm, timeless
Rose Gold
14k - Romantic and contemporary
Platinum
950 - Premium, hypoallergenic, forever
Sterling Silver
925 - Accessible, beautiful, versatile
Private consultation

Start your custom piece.
The first meeting is free.

Call us to set up a private consultation. We'll set aside time just for you, so we can look at your ideas together without rushing.

Call (914) 288-8066
What to expect

Your consultation is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation. We'll look at your inspiration together, talk through options, and give you a clear picture of what's possible within your budget.

Consultations are always free - no commitment required
Walk-ins welcome during store hours - no appointment needed
Bring photos, sketches, or existing pieces - whatever you have
We'll quote you before any work begins
3-4 week turnaround on most custom pieces
Prefer to walk in? We're at 1 S Central Ave, Hartsdale, NY. Mon-Thu 10am-6pm - Fri 10am-12pm - Sun 10am-4pm.
What our customers say

Pieces people wear
every single day.

*****
"We’ve had great experiences at Toby’s. They have made two custom pieces for me that are incredibly beautiful! Their repair service is top notch and extremely reasonably priced. Lovely, honest people!"
Anne Aaronson - Google
*****
"Best jewelers in Westchester. Honest and helpful. Great design work if you want to make something new from something old. Highly recommend. Give them a try."
Jessie Wilkinson - Google
Ready to start?

Your piece is waiting
to be made.

Book a free consultation or walk in anytime. Starting from $500 - 3-4 week turnaround.