Contact & FAQ - Toby's Jewelry - Hartsdale, NY

We're here.
Come say hello.

Walk in anytime, give us a call, or send a message below. 46 years in Westchester means we've answered every question - ask us anything.

Visit us

1 S Central Ave

Hartsdale, NY 10530

Get directions
Call us

(914) 288-8066

Available during store hours

WhatsApp

(914) 288-8066

Message us on WhatsApp
Store hours
Monday 10:00am - 6:00pm
Tuesday 10:00am - 6:00pm
Wednesday 10:00am - 6:00pm
Thursday 10:00am - 6:00pm
Friday 10:00am - 12:00pm
Saturday Closed
Sunday 10:00am - 4:00pm
Follow us

Instagram - Facebook - Google

@realtobysjewelry
Open Google Maps
Send a message

We will get back to you
as soon as we can.

We usually reply within a day or two. For anything urgent, call us at (914) 288-8066 during store hours.

Layaway program

Love it now.
Pay over time.

We offer layaway on all jewelry purchases - no credit check, no interest, no third-party applications. Just a simple agreement between you and us. Put a piece on hold and pay it off at your own pace.

Available on all jewelry purchases

No credit check required

No interest - ever

Flexible payment schedule

Piece held securely until paid in full

Ask in store to get started

1

Choose your pieceFind something you love in our collection or commission a custom design.

2

Make a depositA simple deposit holds the piece while we agree on a payment schedule together.

3

Pay at your paceNo pressure, no third-party interest - pay until the balance is clear.

4

Take it homeOnce paid in full, your piece is yours, beautifully packaged and ready.

Shipping & delivery

Free, insured delivery
anywhere in the US.

Every order ships free and fully insured, with tracking and an adult signature on delivery, so your jewelry arrives safely every time.

Free insured shipping

Every US order ships free, fully insured and tracked by FedEx. No minimum.

Free on every order

In-store pickup

Prefer to pick up? Choose in-store pickup at checkout and collect your piece in Hartsdale.

1 S Central Ave, Hartsdale
Jewelry care

Keep your jewelry
beautiful for life.

Fine jewelry lasts generations with the right care. Here's what we recommend for every piece.

Daily wear

Remove jewelry before showering, swimming, or applying lotions and perfumes. Chemicals and moisture accelerate wear on metal and stones.

Cleaning at home

Warm water, mild dish soap, and a soft toothbrush work for most pieces. Rinse thoroughly and pat dry with a soft cloth.

Storage

Store each piece separately in a soft pouch or lined jewelry box. Diamonds can scratch other stones and metals, so keep them apart.

Professional care

Bring your jewelry in for a free cleaning and inspection once a year. We'll check prongs, clasps, and settings before small issues grow.

Frequently asked questions

Every question.
Honest answers.

Shopping & orders

Do you ship across the US?

Yes, we ship to all 50 states. Shipping is free on every order, fully insured and tracked, with an adult signature on delivery. You can also pick up in store.

Do you offer layaway?

Yes, we offer layaway on all jewelry purchases with no credit check and no interest. Make a deposit, pay at your pace, and take the piece home when it is paid in full. Ask us in store to get started.

Do you offer gift wrapping?

Yes, all pieces come beautifully packaged. Let us know if it is a gift and we will take care of the presentation.

Can I return or exchange a piece?

Yes. Return any unworn piece within 30 days of delivery for a full refund, with its certificates and packaging. Custom-made, engraved and resized pieces are not returnable. Call us or use the form and we will send a free insured return label, or return it in store.

Services & expertise

Do you do jewelry appraisals?

Yes, we provide written appraisals for insurance, estate, and resale purposes. Our appraisals are accepted by all major insurance carriers. Contact us to schedule an appraisal appointment.

How long do repairs take?

Most repairs are ready within 1-10 days. Rush service is available when possible. We will give you a clear timeline and quote before any work begins.

Can you repair any piece of jewelry?

Most people are surprised at what we can restore. Bring it in. The estimate is always free. We handle everything from simple solders to complex restorations.

How long does a custom piece take?

Most custom pieces are ready in 3-4 weeks from design approval. We will give you a precise timeline during your consultation.

Do I need an appointment?

Walk-ins are always welcome for repairs, gold buying, and general shopping. For custom design and engagement ring consultations, booking ahead ensures we have dedicated time ready for you, though walk-ins are welcome for those too.

Lab & natural diamonds

What is the difference between lab and natural diamonds?

Chemically, physically, and optically, there is no difference. Lab diamonds are real diamonds grown in a controlled environment rather than mined. They are IGI certified, have identical hardness and brilliance, and can be up to 70% more affordable.

Can anyone tell it is a lab diamond?

No. Not by sight, not with a standard diamond tester, and not by a jeweler examining it. Only specialized spectroscopy equipment can detect the difference.

How much does a 1ct lab diamond cost?

A top quality 1ct round brilliant lab diamond can start from $499. A similar natural diamond often costs much more depending on grading and availability.

Selling gold & jewelry

How do I sell my gold or jewelry?

Just walk in. No appointment is needed. Bring whatever you have and we will test, weigh, and price everything on the spot using live market rates.

How do you determine what my gold is worth?

We test every piece with our XRF tester, then weigh it and apply the live spot price at that exact moment. You see every step.

What do you do with luxury watches and large diamonds?

We present these to our network of wholesale buyers who bid competitively. We never accept the first offer. Watches can take a few days, and large diamonds can take up to 2 weeks.

Am I obligated to sell once I get a quote?

Absolutely not. Walk away at any point. The evaluation is always free with zero pressure.

Still have questions?

Just ask.
We love to talk jewelry.

Call, message, or walk in. We are open six days a week (closed Saturdays).