Engagement Rings - Hartsdale, NY - Est. 1980

The ring starts
with the right
diamond.

We don't hand you a tray and wish you luck. We sit with you, learn your budget, teach you what matters, and bring you stones to choose from - lab or natural, any shape, any size. The ring gets built around the diamond you love.

$1,000
Starting price
engagement rings
Lab & Natural
Both available -
you decide
Any shape
We source the stone
to fit your vision
46 yrs
Of Westchester
love stories
Our signature experience

Your Diamond Journey.

Most people walk into a jewelry store not knowing what they're looking at. We think that's wrong. At Toby's, your engagement ring experience starts with an education - the 4 C's, what actually matters for your budget, lab vs natural, shapes, and settings.

01
We learn about you
Budget, style preferences, timeline, and whether you're leaning lab or natural. No judgment either way - we meet you where you are.
02
Your diamond education
We walk you through the 4 C's - cut, color, clarity, carat. You'll understand exactly what moves the needle on price and beauty.
03
We bring your options
Based on your budget and preferences, we source stones for you to see in person - any shape, any size, lab or natural.
04
The setting is designed
Inspired by samples, something you found online, or completely from scratch - we design the setting around your stone.
05
You approve everything
Full design and quote presented before a single piece of metal is touched. You approve it, we build it.
06
Ready in 3-4 weeks
Your finished ring, ready to wear - or ready for the moment you've been planning. Comes with full documentation.
The diamond education

The 4 C's - what they
actually mean for you.

Every diamond is graded on four criteria. Understanding them is the difference between making a confident choice and feeling lost.

C
Cut
The most important C. Cut determines how much light the diamond reflects - its brilliance and sparkle.
Always prioritize cut above everything else.
C
Color
Diamonds are graded D to Z. The difference between D and G is nearly invisible to the naked eye, but the price difference is significant.
G-H is the sweet spot for value and beauty.
C
Clarity
Clarity measures inclusions and blemishes. Many inclusions are invisible without magnification.
VS2-SI1 is excellent value - eye clean and beautiful.
C
Carat
Carat is weight, not size. Two diamonds of the same carat can look very different depending on cut and shape.
Shape choice dramatically affects perceived size.

The honest truth: Most people overspend on color and clarity they can't see, and underspend on cut - the one C that makes the biggest visual difference.

Lab or natural?

We carry both.
We push neither.

The choice between lab and natural is personal - and we respect that completely. We'll show you both side by side, explain the real differences honestly, and let you decide what's right for you.

-Lab diamonds are identical in composition, hardness, and brilliance
-IGI certified on all lab stones over 1 carat
-From $499 for a 1ct D-E VVS Triple Ex IGI Certified top quality lab diamond
-Look the same as natural to the eye - always disclosed as lab-grown
Learn About Lab Jewelry
Lab diamond
Natural diamond
1ct VS1 price
From $499
$5,000-$8,000
Composition
Identical
Identical
Hardness
10 Mohs
10 Mohs
Detectable by eye
No
-
Certification
IGI
GIA
Larger stone for budget
Yes - significantly
-
Diamond shapes

Every shape has
a personality.

The shape you choose affects how large the diamond appears, how it catches light, and how it fits your style.

D
Round
Most brilliant. Classic. Timeless.
O
Oval
Appears larger. Elongates the finger.
C
Cushion
Soft corners. Romantic feel.
E
Emerald
Architectural. Bold. Sophisticated.
P
Pear
Unique. Elongating. Statement.
S
Princess
Modern. Angular. Maximum sparkle.
Settings & metals

Available in every
precious metal.

White Gold
14k & 18k - Most popular
Yellow Gold
14k & 18k - Classic
Rose Gold
14k - Romantic
Platinum
950 - Premium forever
Every budget. Every vision.

We work with what
matters to you.

There is no minimum. There is no pressure. We've created extraordinary rings at every price point.

$1,000-$3,500
Beautiful & meaningful
Excellent lab diamond options in this range. A stunning, certified stone in a custom setting.
Lab diamond recommended
$3,500-$8,000
Outstanding quality
Lab or natural both work beautifully here. Strong options in either direction.
Lab or natural - your choice
$8,000-$25,000
Exceptional stones
Natural diamonds in impressive sizes and quality grades with custom settings.
Natural diamond territory
Every piece is quoted before any work begins. No surprises, no pressure, no obligation until you're completely ready.
Private consultation

Start Your
Diamond Journey.

Call us to set up a private consultation. Tell us your budget and what you like, and we'll have stones ready for you when you arrive.

Call (914) 288-8066
What to expect

This is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation. Come as you are - no preparation needed. We'll do the educating, bring the stones, and answer every question honestly.

Consultations are always free - zero commitment required
Walk-ins welcome - no appointment needed to start
We'll have stones ready matching your budget when you arrive
Lab and natural options shown side by side - you decide
Full quote before any work begins - no surprises
Ring ready in 3-4 weeks from approval
Prefer to just walk in? Come by anytime during store hours. 1 S Central Ave, Hartsdale.
What our customers say

Rings worn every day.
Stories told for generations.

*****
"I have been going here for years and they have the best prices in the area. Great service and prices. Just got my wife's engagement ring repaired and it looks fantastic."
Chris Capaccio - Google review
*****
"We’ve had great experiences at Toby’s. They have made two custom pieces for me that are incredibly beautiful! Their repair service is top notch and extremely reasonably priced. Lovely, honest people!"
Anne Aaronson - Google review
Ready to begin?

Your Diamond Journey
starts with one visit.

No appointment required. Walk in, sit down, and let us show you
what the right diamond looks like for you.

1 S Central Ave
Hartsdale, NY 10530
Mon-Thu 10am-6pm - Fri 10am-12pm
Sun 10am-4pm
From $1,000
Lab & natural available