The ring starts
with the right
diamond.
We don't hand you a tray and wish you luck. We sit with you, learn your budget, teach you what matters, and bring you stones to choose from - lab or natural, any shape, any size. The ring gets built around the diamond you love.
engagement rings
you decide
to fit your vision
love stories
Your Diamond Journey.
Most people walk into a jewelry store not knowing what they're looking at. We think that's wrong. At Toby's, your engagement ring experience starts with an education - the 4 C's, what actually matters for your budget, lab vs natural, shapes, and settings.
The 4 C's - what they
actually mean for you.
Every diamond is graded on four criteria. Understanding them is the difference between making a confident choice and feeling lost.
The honest truth: Most people overspend on color and clarity they can't see, and underspend on cut - the one C that makes the biggest visual difference.
We carry both.
We push neither.
The choice between lab and natural is personal - and we respect that completely. We'll show you both side by side, explain the real differences honestly, and let you decide what's right for you.
Every shape has
a personality.
The shape you choose affects how large the diamond appears, how it catches light, and how it fits your style.
Available in every
precious metal.
We work with what
matters to you.
There is no minimum. There is no pressure. We've created extraordinary rings at every price point.
Start Your
Diamond Journey.
Call us to set up a private consultation. Tell us your budget and what you like, and we'll have stones ready for you when you arrive.
Call (914) 288-8066This is a relaxed, no-pressure conversation. Come as you are - no preparation needed. We'll do the educating, bring the stones, and answer every question honestly.
Rings worn every day.
Stories told for generations.
Your Diamond Journey
starts with one visit.
No appointment required. Walk in, sit down, and let us show you
what the right diamond looks like for you.